3. Are subscriber and view counts an accurate measurement of how strong/dedicated/sustainable/whatever a community is?
Not at all. This might sound crass but I swear it’s not. The best analytical measure of how dedicated a community (that I have found) is merch sales. We’ve sold shirts for a lot of people at DFTBA, and I’m always shocked how some channels with 50,000 subs can sell more shirts than channels with 2 million.
View counts are a terrible measure of engagement, subscribers is even worse (since channels that have been around a long time have /tons/ of subs that don’t watch anymore. Not necessarily because the content started to suck, just because people move on and get interested in other stuff.)
If you think about things like how to design thriving communities, this is the most important post you will read today.
Edit: also check out this reblog by sunsetclimber:
It’s funny because I’m part of the Gear/Knife/Gun community on youtube, and it’s so radically different than what Hank is talking about, even though it’s very similar format. The primary difference is that it’s product focused; reviews and test videos are the primary staple. But the demographics are crazy different, instead of 18 and under females, we mostly have males over 20, with a large body of them having kids of their own.
The product-centricity makes for an interesting dynamic, sometimes people who have access to new things that we’re excited about can break into the community with little else; likewise it’s very hard for someone to get noticed reviewing the same things over and over again, unless they have truly different content.
Anyone can ‘like’ a Facebook post or watch a Youtube video with ads because it’s a low barrier to entry. But how many people would actually buy merch, music, or drive 100 miles in the rain at 4am to see you perform?
I constantly say that wanting 200,000 followers is a worthless “numbers game” with no meaning. What matters is the passion and purpose of the community, not the size of it.
-
defcon5 likes this
-
paintme-inmemories likes this
-
apweeks likes this
-
emmas20hr likes this
-
rdhamill likes this
-
daibo1004 likes this
-
mein5000words likes this
-
calvinkaing reblogged this from edwardspoonhands
-
badassbaggins likes this
-
adifferentaspect likes this
-
teafoot likes this
-
thoughtsfromanangel reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
carpaccioy-wasabi likes this
-
beebee9 likes this
-
paternal-reversal likes this
-
theresalwayscloudstofloatupon reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
famousdogsofthecivilwar reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
famousdogsofthecivilwar likes this
-
essceejulies likes this
-
thisisamemorablename likes this
-
afoolsrandommumblings reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
fiftyshadesofgwen likes this
-
djunx likes this
-
merrylovespippin likes this
-
miguelele reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
miguelele likes this
-
burdenedwithgloriousfeels reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
fivecentimeters-per-second likes this
-
puzzelsandsketches reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
lupinkasumi reblogged this from edwardspoonhands
-
theeyebrowofspock reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
shwattsy reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
hannah-banana-1397 likes this
-
psramirez likes this
-
theperksofbeingaweirdflower likes this
-
ollivanders-stele likes this
-
alice-in-randomland reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
muncheswaffles likes this
-
thesassofcas likes this
-
sherlocks-empty-hearse likes this
-
divided-love reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
aliceopal reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
apurplepineapple likes this
-
collarmemaster reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
jellypenguin reblogged this from edwardspoonhands
-
kceverdeene reblogged this from fishingboatproceeds
-
out-there-so-it-isnt-just-me likes this
-
asiafields likes this
-
britzandpieces likes this
-
megnsaysthings reblogged this from edwardspoonhands and added:
Hello Tumblr post that is 1000% relevant to my thesis. Thank you Hank Green for the public interviews. They are awesome...
- Show more notes


