If Cyber Bob illegally downloads Digital Joe’s song from the Internet, it’s crucial to recognize that, in most cases, Joe hasn’t lost anything. For starters, we should stop trying to shoehorn the 21st-century problem of illegal downloading into a moral and legal regime that was developed with a pre- or mid-20th-century economy in mind.

Stuart P. Green: When Stealing Isn’t Stealing - NYTimes.com

via rugnetta

(via kenyatta)

Digital makes it a different game now.

Gotye ‘Somebody I Used to Know’ isn’t creative commons licensed, but because of WOTE’s cover song Gotye shot to #1 on the charts. That’s how the internet works, in some reality. 80% of my income is from people purchasing my orchestra music, and they tell me they found it from torrents or other outlets. People who love my work and other’s work, understand that if we don’t make money then everything stops.

Everyone “steals”: from video converting, hotlinking pictures, mashups, torrents, sharing music, etc. The internet is a group remix of creativity, mashups, and guerilla sharing. It’s fascinating.

But even if you wanted to make the argument about “digital stealing”, then consider this: the problem isn’t THAT people steal, it’s WHY people steal…

Why do people steal groceries or items from a store? I think it’s because of the understaffed stores, horrible UI of self-checkouts, and insanely slow lines.

The problem isn’t that people don’t want to buy merchandise online, the problem is that corporations have made purchasing entertainment online so much more difficult (and a worse library selection) than getting it illegally within seconds.

(via kenyatta)

  1. askdjsoruanything reblogged this from fororchestra
  2. thoughtentity reblogged this from fororchestra
  3. kuryree reblogged this from fororchestra
  4. crazy56u reblogged this from fororchestra
  5. eyes--with--pride reblogged this from shameparade
  6. shameparade reblogged this from fororchestra
  7. starman-jr reblogged this from fororchestra
  8. pantsareneveranoption reblogged this from fororchestra
  9. merumello reblogged this from fororchestra
  10. resiviteten reblogged this from fororchestra
  11. fororchestra reblogged this from kenyatta
  12. drizzleandahurricane reblogged this from rollsinto1
  13. rollsinto1 reblogged this from kenyatta
  14. notyetperfection reblogged this from kenyatta
  15. chartier said: Joe may not have lost anything, but Bob gained something of value without exchanging anything of value in return. It creates a cultural, financial, and psychological quagmire of unequal exchange.
  16. kenyatta posted this
Short URL for this post: http://tmblr.co/ZgmsWyJpZh90